PELEE ISLAND—A proposed 600-foot tower on Pelee Island has set bird conservationists, who want a federal impact assessment, against the US trading firm behind the proposal. The company says it will protect birds, and a township that has already signed off locally, but birding groups and other conservationists are sounding the alarm. Public comments to the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada closed on Monday.
The 182.9-metre tower is to be held up by guy wires and lit at night, to be located at 1246 Centre Dyke Road. According to the Pelee Island Bird Observatory (PIBO), the tower would carry financial trading data between Chicago and New Jersey for DRW, a US-based trading firm, rather than provide cell service.
PIBO cautions that Pelee Island sits where the Atlantic and Mississippi flyways for migratory birds meet, and argues that the tower’s height, wires and lighting could be deadly for birds crossing western Lake Erie. The PIBO goes on to claim that no government has assessed the project’s effect on birds, that the company’s own study did not adequately assess collisions during migration, and that its bird surveys were two counts in June and July 2025, outside migration season.
On October 6, PIBO asked the federal government to designate the project for an impact assessment. The agency began reviewing the request October 21, and a decision is due by January 19. Author Margaret Atwood, PIBO’s founding honorary chair, has joined the campaign, calling it a “Not In Everyone’s Backyard” issue.
Following a call from The Expositor about the issue, Manitoulin Nature Club’s President Phyliss Cacciotti said she was unaware of the issue but would look into it.
“From what I have now researched,” she said in a response, “it seems to have come up on the radar quite suddenly and the public has not had ample opportunity to become informed. Unfortunately, people only have until Monday (November 16) to participate in the petition to the government.”
“The Manitoulin Nature Club finds it atrocious that the federal government has not assessed the project consisting of a 600' tower—equivalent to a 60-storey building—complete with lighting and guy wires, to be erected on Pelee Island where the Atlantic and Mississippi migratory bird flyways intersect,” said Ms. Cacciotti. “Since most songbirds fly at night, the proposed structure will draw in the birds as they will be attracted by the lights. They will then circle the tower and hit the guy wires leading to their death, potentially in the thousands. In 2024-25, more than 660,00 birds were counted and banded on Pelee Island.”
Although the public comment period has passed by the time this article is published, the Manitoulin Nature Club intends to add its weight to the battle against the proposed tower.
“Pelee Island is a Key Biodiversity Area and hosts critical habitat for seven Species at Risk, including the Blue Racer snake that is found only on Pelee in Canada,” continued Ms. Cacciotti. “Towers in the US and Canada have been estimated to kill 68 million birds every year! We cannot allow this tower to be erected in a place where bird lovers from all over the world flock to see migratory birds. We must speak on their behalf, and the Manitoulin Nature Club has circulated a petition to our 176 members wherein people can sign a letter being forwarded to the Minister of the Environment, Climate Change and Nature as well as the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, Ontario region. We have also posted and circulated information on our Facebook page.”
For its part, the company behind the proposed tower are adamant that the tower will have minimal impact on migrating birds.
DRW spokeswoman Caroline Vasquez has been reported in the media as saying that “protecting wildlife has been a priority throughout the project’s planning.” The company says it commissioned an independent environmental impact study, built recommended mitigation measures into the design, and has committed to voluntarily installing what it calls best-in-class bird-collision mitigation technology alongside required aviation lighting. It says it consulted Birds Canada, PIBO and the US Fish and Wildlife Service, and that the project has been through the public consultation process required by Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada. That process ended this past Monday.
In a statement to CTV News Windsor, the company said it welcomed PIBO’s feedback and would continue the dialogue. PIBO disputes that characterization. Board chair Deborah Egan says the group met the company September 23 to gather information and offered advice on bird-safe lighting but is not working with DRW and has not endorsed any part of the plan.
Township of Pelee council granted municipal concurrence for the tower in November 2025, authorizing the mayor and clerk to sign a letter of concurrence for DRW and its agent, Canacre Ltd. Outgoing Mayor Cathy Miller told CTV News Windsor that the township finished its review more than a year ago. PIBO says she has also described the matter as a federal one.
Council records show tower siting has been debated this year, including whether a second proposed tower should share infrastructure with DRW’s. Councillor Dave DeLellis, who asked in August who had seen the associated approvals, was elected mayor October 26 to succeed Ms. Miller, who did not seek re-election.
The Manitoulin ExpositorTom Sasvari
The Manitoulin ExpositorExpositor Staff